Wall Street Ratings Agency Sounds Alarm About Chicago’s Finances Amid Budget Stalemate

Posted
Wall Street Ratings Agency Sounds Alarm About Chicago’s Finances Amid Budget Stalemate Heather Cherone

A Wall Street ratings agency sounded the alarm over Chicago’s finances on Wednesday as the debate over Mayor Brandon Johnson’s $17.6 billion proposed spending plan for 2027 sunk deeper into chaos.

S&P Global, one of a handful of major ratings agencies, put the city’s debt backed by both property taxes and sales taxes on “CreditWatch” with negative implications, according to an analysis released Wednesday. That means analysts see at least a 1-in-2 chance of a cut in the next three months, according to the analysis.

The agency acted “given the current budget stalemate and given that budget negotiations during this critical period appear to be heading down a path similar to that of the past two years, which, in our view, increases the likelihood that the city will resort to significant one-time measures to balance the fiscal 2027 budget,” according to the statement.

Chicago’s general obligation credit rating is BBB with a negative outlook, according to S&P. A credit rating of BBB indicates a government agency has “adequate capacity to meet financial commitments,” but is susceptible to “adverse economic conditions.” It is two notches above a junk rating.

Chicago’s Sales Tax Securitization Corp. credit rating is A+, according to S&P, but the agency also placed that debt on CreditWatch with a negative outlook.

The ratings issued by the major ratings agencies help determine how much the city must pay in interest to borrow money, much like an individual’s credit score.

Chicago has $9.86 billion in debt backed by property tax revenue and an additional $8.94 billion backed by sales tax revenues, according to city records.

Three ratings agencies have downgraded the city’s credit since Johnson took office in 2023.

S&P last downgraded the city’s credit in 2024, just a few months after a similar warning.

Another downgrade “is likely if Chicago’s enacted fiscal 2027 budget relies too heavily on unsustainable solutions to close the gap, perpetuating the city’s chronic reliance on short-term expedients that reduce fiscal resilience,” according to the analysis, which blamed “political infighting” and noted that the deadline for a budget deal is just six weeks away.

That is likely to “make an on-time budget with substantial structural enhancements difficult to achieve,” according to the analysis. “That said, we could affirm the ‘BBB’ rating with progress reducing the deficit through structural measures that meaningfully reduce out-year deficits and place Chicago on a path toward fiscal normalization.”

S&P sounded the alarm about Chicago’s finances just hours after the City Council ordered an independent review of the city’s finances after the abrupt resignation of former Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch on Friday. The S&P analysis said her departure came “at a critical juncture.”

The S&P analysis said Gabrysch’s departure is the latest in “a string of high-profile management departures over the past year that, at this stage, we believe constitutes a pattern of management instability that injects added uncertainty into the budget process.” 

A majority of the Chicago City Council vehemently opposed to Johnson’s plan to bridge a portion of the city’s budget gap — initially pegged at $882.4 million — by taxing large firms.

Johnson’s plan would impose a $25 per month per employee tax on most firms that have more than 125 employees to generate approximately $100 million.

The mayor’s proposal would also hike personal property lease taxes from 15% to 20% to generate $234 million. That tax, which gets added to car and equipment rentals as well as cloud-based software, will ensure that “big tech” firms pay their fair share, Johnson has said.

The two sides are $409 million apart, records show.

Johnson’s proposed “spending plan continues a pattern of heavy reliance on nonstructural gap-closing measures that includes bonding for legal settlements, tax increment finance fund sweeps, use of fund balance, reallocation of corporate fund expenses to other funds, and a hiring freeze at the Chicago Police Department without a permanent headcount reduction,” according to the analysis. “Consequently, most of the measures proposed to close the estimated $882 million corporate fund gap are either nonstructural or contested by a city council majority. Furthermore, expenditure adjustments are significantly limited in the budget proposal, in our view, indicating a limited appetite for cost-cutting that further constrains the budgetary environment.”

Johnson said in a statement that S&P’s action comes as “a sobering reminder” that the city must pass a balanced budget as soon as possible.

“In this moment, we must come together and engage in a good-faith dialogue on behalf of all Chicagoans,” Johnson said. “It’s time to lower our voices and raise our sights.”

Contact Heather Cherone: @HeatherCherone | (773) 569-1863 | hcherone@wttw.com