Police Oversight Board Commissioner on Choosing 3 Finalists for Chicago’s Next Top Cop

Posted
Police Oversight Board Commissioner on Choosing 3 Finalists for Chicago’s Next Top Cop Jessica Watts

In case an ongoing budget battle and a reelection bid weren’t keeping Mayor Brandon Johnson busy enough, Johnson is also facing a looming deadline to select his pick to lead the police force.

Last week, the Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability named three finalists for the role of top cop following former Supt. Larry Snelling’s retirement earlier this year. All three nominees are Chicago Police Department veterans with decades of experience: Angel Novalez, chief of the Office of Community Policing; Chris Papaioannou, chief of the Bureau of Counterterrorism; and Antoinette Ursitti, first deputy superintendent.

The next superintendent will be tasked with working toward court-ordered reforms and continuing efforts to keep shootings and homicides at near-historic lows.

Johnson has until Dec. 12 to make his selection or reject the CCPSA’s choices and request a new list of candidates. If he chooses a candidate, that appointment must be confirmed by the Chicago City Council.

CCPSA commissioner Sandra Wortham joined “Chicago Tonight” to discuss the search process.

On the CCPSA’s top priorities during the search:

“First and foremost, our priority was to hear from the public, to hear from Chicagoans and then take what we heard and fashion our questions and analysis of the candidates based on that community feedback. And that’s what we did. We heard a focus on continuing to decrease crime, fight crime, increase public safety. We heard about relationships with community. We wanted a leader who could continue to foster relationships with community. Of course we know that the city of Chicago is in a consent decree and so (we wanted) someone who could continue to lead the department through that.” 

On why public feedback was important:

“I think for an issue related to public safety, which is the main charge of the Chicago Police Department, it is crucial. We want to have candidates to send to the mayor who will be able to serve all Chicagoans. And that’s a high bar because Chicagoans have varied perspectives on public safety, on policing. And we wanted to make sure that we were able to send candidates to the mayor who could meet all of those needs.”

On appointing the next superintendent before the 2027 mayoral election:

Several alderpeople have argued the next superintendent shouldn’t be chosen until after February’s mayoral election, given that it’s not certain who will lead the city after the next top cop takes over.

“We had a wonderful pool of 46 applicants who are leaders both internally at CPD and across the country in various police agencies. Chicago is a wonderful place. I think this is a wonderful position to lead this amazing department. And I think people who are law enforcement leaders would take this job in any administration, even understanding that there may be some transition.” 

On selecting candidates with varying backgrounds: 

“We have three leaders within CPD with three very different backgrounds, but all, I believe (are) equipped to step into this role and lead this department and work with our residents to do this job. So it wasn’t intentional that we look for three different backgrounds, but that’s just kind of how it worked out. And I think it speaks to the breadth of experience within CPD and what the organization is building in terms of its talent and its leaders that we got three people who are prepared to do this job but all with very different experiences.”


WTTW News coverage of policing and police reform is supported by The Joyce Foundation.