Lindsay Clancy’s New Murder Trial Set for March 29: Prosecutors Stick With First-Degree Charges

Posted

Lindsay Clancy and her attorneys returned to Plymouth Superior Court on Monday, Nov. 16, for a brief scheduling hearing following three major rulings in her triple murder case. By the end of the hearing, a new trial date had been set for March 29, 2027.

Last week, Judge William Sullivan rejected Clancy’s attempt to have the triple murder charges dismissed on double-jeopardy grounds, ruling that the September mistrial was justified after jurors deadlocked 11-1. The majority reportedly favored a finding that she was not criminally responsible for the deaths of her three children.

Sullivan also denied the defense’s request to investigate the lone holdout juror, while rejecting prosecutors’ request for a gag order.

As Los Angeles Magazine previously reported, the decisions left Clancy facing a potential retrial. On Monday, prosecutors confirmed they intend to move forward with the first-degree murder charges, setting off a back-and-forth over when the second trial should begin.

Credit: Los Angeles Magazine

Clancy appeared in court alongside her attorneys, Kevin Reddington and Laura McConnell. Her parents were not initially present but arrived later during the hearing. Patrick Clancy’s attorney, David Meier, also attended.

Assistant District Attorneys Jennifer Sprague and Shannon Buckingham appeared for the prosecution. D.A. Cruz was not present in the courtroom.

Sullivan opened the hearing by announcing that it was time to create a schedule, after seemingly kicking the can down the road for some time. Sprague said prosecutors were ready to select a jury trial date, prompting Reddington to point out that her reference to a jury meant the Commonwealth intended to pursue the first-degree murder charges. If they had dropped to second-degree, a bench trial would be accessible to Clancy.

But agreeing on a date proved difficult.

Sprague initially said prosecutors were unavailable until May, citing other trials already on the calendar. Reddington pushed for April, while Sullivan questioned why a prosecution case dating back to a 2014 incident should take priority over Clancy’s case.

Sprague explained that other defendants had actually already filed motions objecting to the Clancy trial taking precedence over their cases.

Sullivan insisted on a March or April date, floating April 5 before suggesting March 8 and March 15.

At one point, the judge quoted Shakespeare: “Tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow.”

When Sprague responded, “I don’t have any jokes,” Sullivan shot back, “I’m not making any jokes! I’m trying to get a trial date scheduled.” Reddington acknowledged that he also had trials scheduled but said he would make the date work.

The parties eventually settled on March 29, 2027, for Clancy’s new trial.

The court also scheduled another hearing for Dec. 30, 2026, followed by a pretrial conference on Feb. 18, 2027.

Los Angeles approached Reddington after the hearing and asked if he would have preferred a bench trial with Judge Sullivan; he replied, “It depends.”

Clancy, who has pleaded not guilty, is accused of killing her three young children at the family’s Duxbury home in January 2023. Her first trial ended in a mistrial in September after jurors failed to reach a unanimous verdict.

The post Lindsay Clancy’s New Murder Trial Set for March 29: Prosecutors Stick With First-Degree Charges appeared first on LAmag.

Crime, Judge William Sullivan, Kevin Reddington, Lindsay Clancy, Massachusetts, murder, Patrick Clancy