JEFFERSONVILLE, Ind. — A Clark County Circuit Court judge has temporarily blocked Indiana Republicans’ pick for Senate president pro tempore from taking office after his election victory was called into question.
Sen. Chris Garten represents the 45th district in the Indiana Senate, which primarily consists of Clark County. After Election Day, the county had him listed with a 297-vote lead in his reelection campaign.
Senate Republicans elected Garten to lead the Senate in 2027 as president pro tempore not long after Election Day.
However, Indiana Democrats urged the Clark County Election Board to examine the results from the polling place at Jeffersonville High School after they said discrepancies were found.
After the board declined to recount the results, Democrats filed suit asking for a judicial review of the results.
On Monday, a Clark County judge ruled Garten could not take the oath of office for a new term as Senator while the case was being heard, making him ineligible to hold the Senate president pro tempore seat, as only a senator can hold that office.
The ruling said county officials were restrained from certifying the results of Election Day for multiple races, including Garten’s state Senate District 45 election.
“It is therefore ordered that the Clark County Election Board, its members, and the Clerk of the Clark Circuit Court are restrained from certifying the results of the November 3, 2026 general election for the offices of Indiana State Senator, District 45 and Clark County Auditor, and from transmitting a certified statement of the votes cast in Clark County for Indiana State Senator, District 45 under Indiana Code 3-12-5-11; 2. That the Respondent Chris Garten is restrained from presenting himself to take the oath of office as, or to be seated as, the Senator from District 45,” the order reads.
Indiana’s Reorganization Day, when members of the state Senate and House of Representatives meet to formally elect their leaders for the upcoming session and swear in members to new terms is Tuesday.
The ruling said the order will remain in effect “until the court has heard and decided the Petitioner’s request for a preliminary injunction, but not longer than ten (10) days after its entry unless extended.”
Indiana Democratic Party Chair Karen Tallian, Ninth District Indiana Democratic Party Chair Adam Dickey and Clark County Democratic Party Chair Miguel Hampton released a joint statement responding to the ruling.
“The Clark County Circuit Court made the correct decision today by preventing the Clark County Election Board from certifying potentially inaccurate results,” the statement read. “The discrepancies reported are acknowledged by all sides, including the County Election Board and Sen. Chris Garten himself. It should not have taken a court order to get the Election Board to do the right thing. We are thankful the court agrees that the voice of every eligible Hoosier who cast a ballot needs to be heard accurately with the major discrepancies which have been revealed.”
The Indiana Republican Party did not immediately respond to a request for comment.